
Water type starters are no exception to the rule that your starter is likely your main for the whole game. What counts is what it meets in the first few hours: a rival, the trainer who keeps turning up with a starter of his own, then Gym leaders, the boss trainers of the main story, whose types either help it or hurt it.
Each generation gets one Water starter, and they all finish strong, with 528 to 535 base stats, the numbers that add up to a Pokemon's raw strength. So the difference is the start. Some of them get a Rock Gym handed to them on a plate, while others walk straight into an Electric team with nothing to answer it.
What you're up against early

Each game sets its Water starter the same kind of test, with one rival fight and then the first Gyms, which the table lists in the order the leaders are usually met. Water does double damage to Rock and Fire while Grass and Electric do double damage to it, and the leaders' types decide most of the early fights.
| Starter | Game | First three fights |
|---|---|---|
| Mudkip | Ruby and Sapphire | Roxanne (Rock), Brawly (Fighting), Wattson (Electric) |
| Popplio | Sun and Moon | Ilima (Normal), Hala (Fighting) |
| Piplup | Diamond and Pearl | Roark (Rock), Gardenia (Grass), Maylene (Fighting) |
| Sobble | Sword and Shield | Milo (Grass), Nessa (Water), Kabu (Fire) |
| Froakie | X and Y | Viola (Bug), Grant (Rock), Korrina (Fighting) |
| Quaxly | Scarlet and Violet | Katy (Bug), Brassius (Grass), Iono (Electric) |
| Squirtle | Red and Blue | Brock (Rock), Misty (Water), Lt. Surge (Electric) |
| Totodile | Gold and Silver | Falkner (Flying), Bugsy (Bug), Whitney (Normal) |
| Oshawott | Black and White | Cilan (Grass), Lenora (Normal), Burgh (Bug) |
Alola swaps Gyms for trials, its own version of the same boss fights, which leaves Popplio with only Ilima and Hala to worry about.
Mudkip, if you want it easy

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Mud Fish Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0258
- Debut
- Gen III
- Base stat total
- 310
Mudkip walks into Roxanne with every matchup on its side. Her Geodude at level 14 is Rock and Ground, so Water hits it for four times the damage. Her Nosepass at level 15 is a Rock type and takes double. Mud Slap, a Ground move, comes at level 6 and Water Gun at level 10. Brawly's Machop and Makuhita are an even fight after that, with no type bonus either way.
Then comes Wattson, where Mudkip shows off. Marshtomp arrives at level 16 as a Water and Ground type, and Electric moves do nothing to it. Building a whole Gym around Electric moves was a bold plan for Wattson. Mud Slap hits his Magnemite at level 22 and Magneton at level 23 for four times the damage, since both are Electric and Steel. The line ends with Swampert at level 36, a Water and Ground type with 110 Attack, the stat for physical hits, and the highest total of the nine at 535 base stats.
Popplio, with Hala as the prize

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Sea Lion Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0728
- Debut
- Gen VII
- Base stat total
- 320
Popplio's early game hangs on Disarming Voice, a Fairy move it gets at level 8, because Fairy hits Fighting for double. Ilima comes first, and his Yungoos at level 9 and Smeargle at level 10 are Normal types, which is an even fight for Water. Then you reach Hala, whose Mankey and Makuhita at level 14 and Crabrawler at level 15 are all Fighting types, and that trial goes quickly.
From there the line keeps building. Aqua Jet arrives at level 15 and Bubble Beam at level 22, with Brionne in between at level 17. Popplio finishes as Primarina at level 34, a Water and Fairy type with 126 Special Attack, the stat for non-physical moves, and 530 base stats.
Piplup, strong at the start and rough at Gardenia

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Penguin Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0393
- Debut
- Gen IV
- Base stat total
- 314
Piplup starts with a bad matchup, because Barry's Turtwig is the rival fight it gets and Grass does double damage to Water. A good run comes straight after it. Roark's Geodude and Onix at level 12 are Rock and Ground and take four times the damage from Water, while his Cranidos at level 14 takes double.
Gardenia is the speed bump. Her Cherubi and Turtwig at level 19 and Roserade at level 22 are Grass types, and Grass hits Water for double. Peck, a Flying move Piplup learns at level 15, hits Grass for double, and that's your way through. We respect a penguin that solves a flower problem by pecking it. After her, Maylene's Fighting team is an even fight, and Fantina's Ghost team in Platinum, the extended Sinnoh edition, is an even fight too. Prinplup arrives at level 16 and Empoleon at level 36, a Water and Steel type with 111 Special Attack and 530 base stats.
Sobble, until Milo

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Water Lizard Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0816
- Debut
- Gen VIII
- Base stat total
- 310
Hop's Scorbunny is the rival fight Sobble gets, and Water does double damage to Fire, which makes the first test a gift. Milo takes all of that back. His Gossifleur at level 19 and Eldegoss at level 20 are Grass types, and Grass hits Water for double. Sobble learns Water Gun at level 6 and Water Pulse at level 12, and both do half damage to Grass.
Things calm down at Nessa. Her Goldeen at level 22 and Arrokuda at level 23 are Water types, which resist Water, taking half the damage, and Drednaw at level 24 is Water and Rock and ends up even. Then Kabu, where Sobble finally wins. His Ninetales and Arcanine at level 25 are Fire types. His Centiskorch is Fire and Bug, and Water does double damage to all three. Drizzile arrives at level 16 and Inteleon at level 35, a Water type with 125 Special Attack and 530 base stats.
Froakie, solid and never in trouble

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Bubble Frog Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0656
- Debut
- Gen VI
- Base stat total
- 314
Froakie never runs into a Gym that's built to beat it. Viola's Surskit at level 10 and Vivillon at level 12 are Bug types, and Water does normal damage to Bug. Surskit's Water half resists Water, which leaves Quick Attack to do the work there. Grant comes next with Amaura at level 25, a Rock and Ice type, and Water hits Rock for double. His Tyrunt is Rock and Dragon, and the Dragon half cancels the bonus.
Korrina's Mienfoo, Machoke and Hawlucha are Fighting types, and Water is even against them. Froakie learns Bubble at level 5 and Water Pulse at level 14. Frogadier arrives at level 16 and Greninja at level 36, a Water and Dark type with 122 Speed, the stat that decides who moves first, and 530 base stats.
Quaxly, until it meets Iono

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Duckling Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0912
- Debut
- Gen IX
- Base stat total
- 310
Quaxly's Wing Attack arrives at level 10, and Flying hits Bug and Grass for double, which suits the Bug and Grass Pokemon in those fights. Katy's Nymble and Tarountula at level 14 are Bug types, and Brassius's Petilil and Smoliv at level 16 are Grass types. Water also hits his Sudowoodo at level 17 for double, since it's a Rock type.
Then Iono puts an end to the good times. Her Wattrel, Bellibolt and Luxio at level 23 are all Electric, Electric does double damage to Water, and Quaxly has nothing that hits Electric for double. Bringing a friend to that one is no shame, and the duck would agree. Quaxwell arrives at level 16 and Quaquaval at level 36, a Water and Fighting type with 120 Attack and 530 base stats.
Squirtle, with Lt. Surge waiting

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Tiny Turtle Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0007
- Debut
- Gen I
- Base stat total
- 314
Squirtle has to get past Blue's Bulbasaur first, and Grass does double damage to Water. Brock pays you back straight away. His Geodude at level 12 and Onix at level 14 are Rock and Ground and take four times the damage from Water, and Squirtle has Bubble at level 8. Misty's Staryu at level 18 and Starmie at level 21 resist Water, and that Gym is an even fight at best.
Surge is the problem waiting at the end. His Voltorb at level 21, Pikachu at level 18 and Raichu at level 24 are all Electric, which hits Water for double, and Squirtle has no answer. Wartortle arrives at level 16 and Blastoise at level 36, a Water type with 105 Special Defense, the stat against non-physical moves, and 530 base stats.
Totodile, with no help from the type chart

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Big Jaw Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0158
- Debut
- Gen II
- Base stat total
- 314
Silver's Chikorita is the rival fight Totodile gets, and Grass does double damage to Water. After that, Johto's first Gyms don't help or hurt. Falkner's Pidgey and Pidgeotto, at levels 7 and 9, are Normal and Flying types, Bugsy's team is Bug and Whitney's is Normal. Water does normal damage to all of them, and none of them hits Water for double.
Water Gun arrives at level 13, then Bite at level 20. Totodile becomes Croconaw at level 18 and Feraligatr at level 30, a Water type with 105 Attack and 530 base stats. A month of trading even fights with a man and his Pidgey is not the liveliest.
Oshawott, last behind Cilan

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Sea Otter Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0501
- Debut
- Gen V
- Base stat total
- 308
Cheren's Snivy is the rival fight Oshawott gets, and Cilan is next, which makes it Grass twice in a row. His Pansage at level 14 is a Grass type, and Grass hits Water for double. Water Gun comes at level 7 and Razor Shell, a stronger Water move, at level 17. Lenora's Herdier and Watchog, at levels 18 and 20, are Normal types, which is an even fight.
Burgh gives you a bit of both. Dwebble at level 21 is Bug and Rock, and Water hits the Rock half for double. Leavanny at level 23 is Bug and Grass, and its Grass moves hit Oshawott for double. No sea otter should have this much Grass trouble. Dewott arrives at level 17 and Samurott at level 36, a Water type with 108 Special Attack and 528 base stats, the lowest of the nine.
So which one should you pick?

| Rank | Starter | Game | Final form | Base stats |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Mudkip | Ruby and Sapphire | Swampert | 535 |
| 2 | Popplio | Sun and Moon | Primarina | 530 |
| 3 | Piplup | Diamond and Pearl | Empoleon | 530 |
| 4 | Sobble | Sword and Shield | Inteleon | 530 |
| 5 | Froakie | X and Y | Greninja | 530 |
| 6 | Quaxly | Scarlet and Violet | Quaquaval | 530 |
| 7 | Squirtle | Red and Blue | Blastoise | 530 |
| 8 | Totodile | Gold and Silver | Feraligatr | 530 |
| 9 | Oshawott | Black and White | Samurott | 528 |
Mudkip hits Roxanne's team hard and takes nothing from Wattson's Electric moves. Popplio's Fairy move hits Hala's Fighting team for double, and Piplup's Water hits Roark's Geodude and Onix for four times the damage. Squirtle and Quaxly start well and then hit an Electric wall, which is worth knowing before you commit. Oshawott meets a Grass type at Cilan, and Burgh mixes a Rock half that Water hits for double with a Grass type that hits Oshawott for double. All nine finish between 528 and 535 base stats. The pages for generation 1, generation 2, generation 3, generation 4, generation 5, generation 6, generation 7, generation 8 and generation 9 cover each trio in full.
FAQ
What is the best Water type starter?
Mudkip meets Roxanne's Rock team first, which Water hits for double or more, and Marshtomp takes no damage from Wattson's Electric moves.
Which Water type starter has the strongest final form?
That's Swampert if you go by base stats, with 535. The others have 530, except Samurott with 528.
Does Squirtle beat Lt. Surge?
No, because Lt. Surge's Voltorb, Pikachu and Raichu are all Electric, which hits Water for double, and Squirtle has no answer to them at that point.






