
Picking between the Pokemon Emerald starters, the Pokemon you choose at the very beginning of the game, looks like a small decision. It isn't, because whichever one you take will probably stay on your team until the credits roll. That makes it your main for the whole game, and the first few hours decide how the choice feels, since Emerald sends you straight into a run of early Gyms, the battles that hand out badges, and each starter handles them in its own way.
So the question is how much of a fight you want at the start. The difference between the three is whether your first badges come easy or make you work for them.
What you're up against early

Your first battle is against your rival, Brendan or May, on Route 103. At level 5 neither Pokemon has learned anything past its starting moves. That makes it a quick, even fight and nothing to lose sleep over.
The Gyms are where it gets interesting, and a Pokemon's type decides which moves hit it hard or barely at all. Roxanne in Rustboro City leads with Rock types, a pair of Geodude at level 12 and a Nosepass at level 15. Brawly in Dewford Town follows with Fighting types, bringing a Machop and a Meditite at level 16 and a Makuhita at level 19. After him comes Wattson in Mauville City with an Electric team, made up of Voltorb and Electrike at level 20, Magneton at 22 and Manectric at 24.
| Gym | Leader | Type | Their Pokemon |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rustboro City | Roxanne | Rock | Geodude (Lv 12), Geodude (Lv 12), Nosepass (Lv 15) |
| Dewford Town | Brawly | Fighting | Machop (Lv 16), Meditite (Lv 16), Makuhita (Lv 19) |
| Mauville City | Wattson | Electric | Voltorb (Lv 20), Electrike (Lv 20), Magneton (Lv 22), Manectric (Lv 24) |

*Gym leader Roxanne in Pokemon Emerald*

*Gym leader Brawly in Pokemon Emerald*

*Gym leader Wattson in Pokemon Emerald*
That order of Rock, Fighting and Electric is worth remembering, because it hands one starter a gift and another a problem.
Mudkip, if you want it easy

- Type
- Water
- Category
- Mud Fish Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0258
- Debut
- Gen III
- Base stat total
- 310
Mudkip learns Water Gun at level 10, which lands right on time for Roxanne. Geodude is part Rock and part Ground, a combination Water hits very hard. Nosepass is Rock only, and Water still has the edge there, but by less.
Brawly is a fairer fight. By then Mudkip has evolved, meaning it has turned into a stronger form, Marshtomp, at level 16, and while it has no edge against Fighting types, it isn't weak to them either. Makuhita at level 19 is the one that can hit hard, although a few extra levels sort that out.
Then comes Wattson, which is where Mudkip shows off. Marshtomp picked up the Ground type when it evolved, and Electric moves do nothing at all to Ground, which leaves Voltorb, Electrike and Manectric unable to touch it. Magneton takes heavy damage from Ground moves too, including the Mud-Slap Mudkip learned back at level 6. We'd feel bad for Wattson, but only a little. The whole run leads to Swampert, whose only weakness in the whole game is Grass.
Treecko, somewhere in the middle

- Type
- Grass
- Category
- Wood Gecko Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0252
- Debut
- Gen III
- Base stat total
- 310
Treecko gets a comfortable first Gym as well. It learns Absorb at level 6, and Grass moves punish Geodude and land heavily on Nosepass too. Roxanne's Ground moves don't do much to a Grass type either, and Rustboro goes smoothly.
Brawly is even, same as with Mudkip, although Grovyle is fast at 95 speed.
Wattson is where Treecko slows down. Grass resists Electric, meaning it takes less damage from those moves, so his attacks won't hurt much. Your Grass moves only do normal damage back, though, and Magneton resists them as well. It won't lose you the Gym, but it's a long fight that might need a second Pokemon. If you like a start that's mostly comfortable with one stubborn moment, Treecko fits, and it grows into Sceptile, the fastest of the final forms at 120 speed.
Torchic, if you want a challenge

- Type
- Fire
- Category
- Chick Pokémon
- National Dex
- #0255
- Debut
- Gen III
- Base stat total
- 310
Torchic walks into its first Gym at a disadvantage. Fire only does reduced damage to Rock types, Geodude included, while Roxanne's Rock moves hit Torchic hard, so going in with Torchic alone is rough. The easy way out is to catch a Grass type before Rustboro and let a Grass move do the work. You can also grind Torchic, meaning you fight wild Pokemon for experience, until it sits a few levels above Roxanne's team and can push through.
Once you're past her, things turn around. Torchic becomes Combusken at level 16, the same level it learns Peck, and Peck hits Fighting types hard, which helps against Brawly, though his Meditite is part Psychic and Combusken's Fighting type is weak to Psychic.
Against Wattson, Combusken sits in a good spot. Electric moves only do normal damage to it, and Magneton, the one Treecko has to work against, takes heavy damage from both Fire and Fighting moves. The hard start pays off later too, because Blaziken has 120 attack, the highest of the final forms, and two strong attacking types in Fire and Fighting.
So which one should you pick?

| Starter | Roxanne | Brawly | Wattson | How the start feels |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mudkip | Easy | Even | Easy | Smoothest |
| Treecko | Easy | Even | Slow against Magneton | Mostly comfortable |
| Torchic | Hard | Good | Good | Toughest first badge |
If you want to enjoy the opening without fighting the game, Mudkip's type matchups against Roxanne and Wattson are favorable. If you'd rather have the first Gym test you, Torchic gives you that and then does better against Wattson, with Brawly mostly in its favor. Treecko sits between the two, comfortable until Magneton digs in. Since this Pokemon is probably going to be with you for the whole adventure, liking the look of one is a perfectly good reason to choose it.
FAQ
What is the best starter in Pokemon Emerald?
Mudkip's Water Gun lines up with Roxanne's Rock team, its Ground type from Marshtomp blocks Wattson's Electric moves, and Brawly's Fighting types are neutral against it. Which one suits you depends on how much challenge you want early.
Which Emerald starter is the fastest?
Treecko's line is the quickest of the group. Sceptile has 120 speed, the highest of the final forms, ahead of Blaziken's 80 and Swampert's 60.






