Pokepedia

Pokemon Red Starters: Which One to Pick

Pokemon Red Starters: Which One to Pick

Choosing between the Pokemon Red starters can feel like a coin flip when you're standing in Oak's Lab, although the choice deserves more thought than that. Your starter stays on your team for a long stretch of the game, which makes it your main, and the early Gyms, where a leader battles you for a badge, decide how that goes. Every Pokemon and move has a type, and a good matchup deals extra damage while a bad one deals less. Kanto opens with a Rock Gym, then a Water Gym, and an Electric Gym after that, which is plenty of type trouble for a new team.

So the real question is how much of a fight you want early on. Bulbasaur, Charmander and Squirtle all grow into strong Pokemon, and what changes is how much trouble you get from Brock and Misty, and then from Lt. Surge. Pokemon Blue shares Red's data, which means all of it holds for both games.

What you're up against early

A wild battle in Pokemon Red and Blue

Your first battle is against your rival, Blue, right there in Oak's Lab. He picks the starter with the type edge over yours, and he only has that single level 5 Pokemon, so it's over quickly. Bulbasaur meets Charmander, Squirtle meets Bulbasaur and Charmander meets Squirtle.

From there, the Gyms are where the starters split apart. Brock in Pewter City uses Rock types, a Geodude at level 12 and an Onix at level 14. Misty in Cerulean City comes next with Water types, a Staryu at level 18 and a Starmie at level 21. Then Lt. Surge in Vermilion City runs an Electric team, with a Pikachu at level 18 and a Voltorb at level 21 ahead of his Raichu at level 24.

GymLeaderTypeTheir Pokemon
Pewter CityBrockRockGeodude (Lv 12), Onix (Lv 14)
Cerulean CityMistyWaterStaryu (Lv 18), Starmie (Lv 21)
Vermilion CityLt. SurgeElectricPikachu (Lv 18), Voltorb (Lv 21), Raichu (Lv 24)

Bulbasaur, if you want it easy

Bulbasaur official artwork
Type
GrassPoison
Category
Seed Pokémon
National Dex
#0001
Debut
Gen I
Base stat total
318

Bulbasaur starts with Growl and Tackle, picks up Leech Seed at level 7 and gets Vine Whip at level 13, and Vine Whip is the move you're waiting for. Rock types take extra damage from Grass moves, which puts Brock in real trouble once you have it. His Geodude sits at level 12 and his Onix at level 14, so a little training before Pewter City pays off. We'd feel sorry for Brock, but he did bring rocks to a leaf fight. Misty is just as kind, because Grass also deals extra damage to Water types, and her Staryu and Starmie go the same way.

Lt. Surge is where Bulbasaur gets a break instead of an edge. His Pokemon are all Electric, and Grass takes reduced damage from Electric moves, while your Grass moves only hit them for normal damage. That leaves the fight without an edge for you to lean on. Bulbasaur grows into Ivysaur at level 16 and Venusaur at level 32, a Grass and Poison type with 525 base stats, the total of its core battle numbers.

Squirtle, easy until Lt. Surge

Squirtle official artwork
Type
Water
Category
Tiny Turtle Pokémon
National Dex
#0007
Debut
Gen I
Base stat total
314

Squirtle starts with Tackle and Tail Whip and learns Bubble at level 8, well before you reach Brock. Water moves deal extra damage to Rock types, which sends Geodude and Onix down fast and leaves Pewter City with very little to worry about. Misty is an even fight, though, because Water types resist Water moves, meaning they take reduced damage. Bubble and Water Gun, which arrives at level 15, don't do much against Staryu or Starmie, and Wartortle arrives at level 16 while Water moves are still resisted.

Lt. Surge is the real problem. Electric moves deal extra damage to Water types, and his whole team is Electric, while your Water moves only do normal damage back. Bring a Grass or Ground type for that fight, since Electric moves do little to Grass and nothing to Ground. Squirtle becomes Blastoise at level 36, a Water type with 530 base stats.

Charmander, if you want a challenge

Charmander official artwork
Type
Fire
Category
Lizard Pokémon
National Dex
#0004
Debut
Gen I
Base stat total
309

Charmander gets no help from its type at the early Gyms. It knows Growl and Scratch, learns Ember at level 9 and adds Leer at level 15. Scratch is a Normal move and Rock resists it, and Ember has only just arrived at level 9, which leaves you hitting Geodude and Onix for very little. Catch something else for Brock, because Ember is trying its best and we'd hate to watch it try any longer. Misty offers no relief, since Water types take reduced damage from Fire, and her Staryu and Starmie hit back with Water moves that deal extra damage to you.

Lt. Surge is the one fair fight of the early game. Electric moves do normal damage to Fire and Fire moves do normal damage to Electric, which leaves neither side with an edge. Charmeleon arrives at level 16, and by level 36 you have Charizard, a Fire and Flying type with 534 base stats, the highest total among the final forms of these starters.

So which one should you pick?

The overworld in Pokemon Red and Blue
StarterBrockMistyLt. SurgeHow the start feels
BulbasaurEasyEasyEvenSmoothest
SquirtleEasyEvenDisadvantageEasy, then a tougher fight
CharmanderUphillDisadvantageEvenToughest start

If you'd like the early Gyms to go smoothly, Bulbasaur gives you the type edge over Brock and Misty and takes reduced damage at Lt. Surge. Squirtle handles Brock just as well, and after that it needs a backup for Lt. Surge. Charmander hands you a rougher road, with the most base stats of the final forms waiting at the end of it.

To see how the same starters look across the whole generation, try the starters of generation 1.

FAQ

What is the best starter in Pokemon Red?

Bulbasaur has the type edge on Brock and Misty, and it takes reduced damage from Lt. Surge's Electric moves. That makes for a smooth start, although how much of a fight you want early is still your call.

Does Blue pick a starter that beats yours?

Yes, he takes Charmander against Bulbasaur, Bulbasaur against Squirtle and Squirtle against Charmander, always at level 5.

Does Charmander beat Lt. Surge?

No, because neither side has a type edge and the fight comes down to levels.